It’s been months since I’ve seen Z. Our schedules finally lined up and we were able to meet for dinner last week. We met at Toloache. I’ve passed the restaurant a few times and obvs got excited after reading Sam Sifton’s review, I figured it would be a good bet. Z and I have similar palettes and often fall victim of wanting more than we can eat. So of course we started off with the trio of guacamole. The Tradicional was mild which usually doesn’t do it for me, but this had incredible fresh ingredients.
A blend of avocado, tomato, onion, cilantro, serrano apple salad and Mexican cheeses. We loved it! The Frutas, medium guacamole was nay the best.
It looged great. And the ingredient list also looked good I mean what’s not to love about avocado, pomegranate, vidalia onion, mango, apple, peach, habanero and thai basil? Unfortunately, it didn’t quite live up the expectations. We’re a fan of spice so maybe that’s why this one didn’t do it for us, but maybe it would work for someone else. Our favorite was def the Rojo.
A spicy guacamole filled with avocado, tomato, red onion, chipotle and queso fresco. YUM. They also had this fantastic salsa.
We definitely asked for another bowl. We almost filled up on the guacamoles and chips, but of course we also ordered a couple of other dishes. In unison we ordered the Langosta.
Two spicy lobster tacos, morita salsa and avocado. Heavenly!! I really loved the tacos. They were well seasoned the lobster was amazing and it was an ample amount too which isn’t usually the case. They do come in corn tortillas though and I’m very much a fan of flour so I was a tad disappointed. Of course our last item was the Camarones Toloache.
Quite the presentation, no? A plate of roasted garlic shrimp, crispy tortilla, black beans, chayote squash "spaghetti salad" and cascabel salsa. I was a tad overwhelmed. The combination of flavors was good but the crispy tortilla was definitely necessary amidst what sometimes felt like a pile of mush. They could have also kicked it up a notch with a variety of spices but otherwise it was good. While I was stuffed to the brim, I was of course in favor of ordering dessert. We went with the Pastel de Chocolate.
Warm Mexican chocolate cake with dulce de leche ice cream. Awesome! There's a lot to be happy about when there's chocolate oozing out of chocolate. The ice cream made it even better! Toloache was great. The food was good and the company was better. It also has a very lively atmosphere and the staff is extremely attentive. Rare to find a decent restaurant in midtown amidst all the pre-theater spots.